The Supernatural: A Brief Theological Examination
Pantheists who maintain that the nature of God and the nature of the universe are the same must and do deny the existence of the supernatural. God is the immanent principle in nature (and evolution) for them, and so there is no supernatural.
Deists admit an essential distinction between God and the universe, but deny the action of God in human affairs, and so deny the supernatural.
Semi-Rationalists admit an essential distinction between God and nature, and admit also the possibility of miraculous intervention, but deny, with regard to God, the distinction between natural mysteries, and supernatural mysteries. Hence they admit the possibility of a supernatural effect-a miracle- but deny the possibility of supernatural truth.
The orthodox Christian understanding of the supernatural is, again, that which is above created nature, inasmuch as it exceeds the powers and exigencies of any created nature, although it does not exceed the passive perfectible capacity of created nature, nor the suitability of created nature to receive it. The supernatural, then, is twofold:
1. Supernatural miracles which exceed the power and exigency of created nature, but do not exceed the comprehension of the intellect.
2. Supernatural mysteries in the strict sense, and supernatural grace and glory. These exceed not only the power and exigency, but even the comprehension of any created intellectual nature.
The supernatural is further divided into that which is essentially supernatural, and that which is modally supernatural.
That which is essentially supernatural exceeds the limits and comprehension of any created nature. The Trinity is an example of an essentially supernatural fact.
That which is modally supernatural is some natural fact or quality produced or arranged in a supernatural way. The resurrection of Lazarus, for example, was natural in itself as nature gives life, but supernatural in the manner of its accomplishment.
There is nothing in the theological definition of supernatural that leaves room for so-called "paranormal" activity, as these belong to a different class of spiritual phenomena. The supernatural is entirely the effect of God directly intervening in human affairs, while angelic (including demonic) intervention/interference is more properly known as "preternatural."